One of the reoccuring themes in Goethe's "The Sorrows of Young Werther" is this idea that life is only a dream -- a fact which he states on page eleven; "That the life of man is but a dream is a thought which has occurered to many people, and I myself am constantly haunted by it. When I see the limitations which imprison the active a speculative faculties of man; when I see how all human activity is directed toward procuring satisfaction for needs that have no other purpose than prolonging our miserable eistence; when I see, moreover, how any comfort we may derive from certain points of inquiry is merely a dream-like kind of resignation..."
Throughout the rest of the novel, Werther acts on these ideas and at times lives in a world of complete imagination, selfishly, in order to comfort his own aching heart. Whenever he is with Lotte, he imagines embracing her or touching her hands, before he meets Albert, he imagines him as a tyrant and near the end of the book he confesses to dreaming that a note Lotte has left for Albert is actually left for him. Werther spends half of his time living in a make-believe world, he is completely involved in himself and this world he creates.
Werther's imagination is, I think, a large contributer to his final decision to free himself of his misery. Because the world he imagines and the world in which he lives are so different, going back and forth from one world to the other would drive anyone crazy. Yet, don't we all slip into an imaginary world at times? A completely self-centered world in which we get everything we want and care nothing for the wants of others? We use our imaginations for comfort, just as Werther does, but perhaps there is a limit which we shouldn't exceed when we make-believe. What pushes Werther over the edge is perhaps his lack of restraint on this imaginary world; he slips into it almost everytime he is with Lotte. It simultaneously makes him happy and miserable. Like a drug, Werther becomes addicted to his imagination, and finds that it is impossible to try and live in both worlds.
Wednesday, September 26, 2007
"What is Enlightenment?", Kant's 1784 essay was written in response to the question (what it enlightenment) posed by Reverend Johann Friedrich Zollner. Zollner was an official in the Prussian government in the 18th century. He posed his question to the entire public in a rebuttal-like movement to Biester's essay titled: "Proposal, not to engage the clergy any longer when marriages are conducted". Many intellectuals responded with essays but Kant's is the most famous and made the biggest impact.
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
a ramble.
Throughout his discourse on the nature of inequality, Rousseau illustrates every glitch and problem that civillized man brings upon himself and his fellow man in society. He makes his discontent with his own society quite apparent throughout the entire essay and draws the reader's attention to the flaws in even the most highly respected ancient civilizations such as Rome and Athens. I began to wonder what kind of society would be most pleasurable for Rousseau. I certainly don't think he would be very content to live amongst the trees without knowledge or anyway to appease his philosophical, curious mind which any man or woman is inclined to have. No, surely his powder-white wig would not fare well with the other woodland creatures either-- although it might come in handy during heavy rainfall. So if not amongst nature, living like any other mammal, what then? I don't think Rousseau would have been pleased to have been born in today's America in which the majority of its citizens feigns equality and in reality lives in constant struggle beneath one another. Would he be content to live in a purely socialist society? Where everyone is, by law, living on the same level and where equality is controlled? Help us Rousseau, lay out your plan for a perfect and livable society so that we can all be content and equal!
"I would have chosen a republic where the individuals, being content with sanctioning the laws and making decisions in addembllies on proposals from the leaders on the most important public business...Such, Magnificent, Most Honoured and Sovereign Lords, are the advantages I would have sought in the country I would have chosen as my own. And if Providence had added to all those merits a charming location, a temperate climate, a fertile countryside, and the most delectable appearance of any place nder the sun, I would have wished to complete my fortuen by enjoing all these advantages in the bosom of that happy country, living peacefully in sweet society with my fellow citizens, and, taking my example from them...and leaving after me the honourable memory of a good man and an upright, virtuous patriot" (Roussea 61).
Oh, I see now, well gee, what are we waiting for? Let's go get this sunny countryside that is fertile all year round and start up a few businesses so that the owners of those businesses could govern the people (fairly and justly of course). Of course! How could we not have thought of this before? A "magnificent", honorable, and just panel of rulers to help us citizens govern ourselves and always keep us equal. Hm.
Even as the ink left his quill (or whatever he used to pen these words onto paper) he must have known that what he writes of can not and will not exist. The principles and ideas are nice enough, but I think it is our human nature which prevents them from being truly carried out for a prolonged period of time. Even if a society started as the one he describes, a community based on idealistic foundations of how it should behave and govern, these base attributes would be contorted and distored as the society grew and there would undoubtedly be rifts and corruption resulting in the peoples' tribulation. It is human inclination to be competitive and to yearn to be better. It is human nature to be unequal. Rousseau even says that the fault of man is his "faculty of self-improvement". In nature, the better man is the one with the most food and the one with the most food gains power. As Rousseau points out, it is from this point that civilized society is born.
I don't think the destruciton of Man's freedom comes from the society in which he lives. Society, community, rules, laws, competition, self-betterment, all of these things I think are inevitable. It is in our nature to create society. It is only the individual who can decide how free he or she wants to be. To be truly free, one must reject all societies and resolve to live alone and by one's own laws.
Man is only as free as he lets himself be. It is in our nature to strive for equality but remain unequal. Freedom results in the individual's revolt against society and resolution to make him or herself into a lone and true outcast.
"I would have chosen a republic where the individuals, being content with sanctioning the laws and making decisions in addembllies on proposals from the leaders on the most important public business...Such, Magnificent, Most Honoured and Sovereign Lords, are the advantages I would have sought in the country I would have chosen as my own. And if Providence had added to all those merits a charming location, a temperate climate, a fertile countryside, and the most delectable appearance of any place nder the sun, I would have wished to complete my fortuen by enjoing all these advantages in the bosom of that happy country, living peacefully in sweet society with my fellow citizens, and, taking my example from them...and leaving after me the honourable memory of a good man and an upright, virtuous patriot" (Roussea 61).
Oh, I see now, well gee, what are we waiting for? Let's go get this sunny countryside that is fertile all year round and start up a few businesses so that the owners of those businesses could govern the people (fairly and justly of course). Of course! How could we not have thought of this before? A "magnificent", honorable, and just panel of rulers to help us citizens govern ourselves and always keep us equal. Hm.
Even as the ink left his quill (or whatever he used to pen these words onto paper) he must have known that what he writes of can not and will not exist. The principles and ideas are nice enough, but I think it is our human nature which prevents them from being truly carried out for a prolonged period of time. Even if a society started as the one he describes, a community based on idealistic foundations of how it should behave and govern, these base attributes would be contorted and distored as the society grew and there would undoubtedly be rifts and corruption resulting in the peoples' tribulation. It is human inclination to be competitive and to yearn to be better. It is human nature to be unequal. Rousseau even says that the fault of man is his "faculty of self-improvement". In nature, the better man is the one with the most food and the one with the most food gains power. As Rousseau points out, it is from this point that civilized society is born.
I don't think the destruciton of Man's freedom comes from the society in which he lives. Society, community, rules, laws, competition, self-betterment, all of these things I think are inevitable. It is in our nature to create society. It is only the individual who can decide how free he or she wants to be. To be truly free, one must reject all societies and resolve to live alone and by one's own laws.
Man is only as free as he lets himself be. It is in our nature to strive for equality but remain unequal. Freedom results in the individual's revolt against society and resolution to make him or herself into a lone and true outcast.
Tuesday, September 11, 2007
Rousseau and Supertramp
Reading Rousseau's "A Discourse on Inequality" reminded me a lot of the story of Chris McCandless a.k.a Alexander Supertramp which is told by Jon Krakauer in his book "Into The Wild" and now by Sean Penn in the film with the same title. Chris McCandless donates everything he owns, destroys the things he can't give away -- including his identity -- and embarks on a journey through America. He spends a fair amount of time traveling within civilization but then heads into the wild of Alaska to live like a savage (with the help of some books and tools). He, like Rousseau, rejects society and sees the limitations and alterations its made on the true nature of man. He leaves his old world behind in order to live as man should. His is a story of Man vs. Society as well as Man vs. Nature.
I saw the film at Cantor last week and while I must say I was not impressed with Sean Penn's work, Alexander Supertramp's ideas portrayed in the film were captivating. Here's a link to the trailer...
http://www.apple.com/trailers/paramount_vantage/intothewild/small.html
I saw the film at Cantor last week and while I must say I was not impressed with Sean Penn's work, Alexander Supertramp's ideas portrayed in the film were captivating. Here's a link to the trailer...
http://www.apple.com/trailers/paramount_vantage/intothewild/small.html
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)